There Are Too Many Damn Rules We’re Expected To Follow When Criticizing Israel And Zionism

Comedian Bowen Yang is issuing groveling apologies for accidentally saying one of the Anti-Defamation League’s 48,000 banned antisemitic no-no phrases, and the ADL is of course rejecting his apologies saying he didn’t grovel hard enough.

Bowen called genocide apologist Regina Spektor a “Zio”, short for Zionist, during a podcast last month. Some Israel supporter listened to the podcast episode recently, and now Bowen is in the middle of a celebrity PR crisis because pro-Israel spinmeisters are claiming he said an “antisemitic slur”.

That’s it. That’s the whole entire story. A comedy podcaster said the first two syllables of a three-syllable word.

I know this happened because a ridiculous amount of media attention has gone into telling me about this complete non-story, with outlets like The New York Times, The Independent, USA Today, Rolling Stone, Variety, People, and Us Weekly publishing entire news articles about Yang’s use of the aforementioned no-no word.

“I want to genuinely apologize for using a word on the podcast without knowing its antisemitic history, especially since we’ve repudiated antisemitism on the show as recently as the last two weeks,” Yang said in a statement. “Particularly upsetting to realize that I adopted language popularized by far-right movements whose rhetoric we should be wary of and act against.”

Here’s what ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt said in response to Bowen’s apology:

“Bowen Yang — Thank you for giving the public a textbook example of normalizing antisemitism.

“First, you breezily used the antisemitic slur ‘Zio’ on your show, got called out for it, and then issued a meager apology. You claimed not to know the history of the term, explaining you were upset to learn it was popularized by far-right white supremacists.

“Are you kidding me? The problem to you wasn’t that you used an antisemitic slur; the problem was that you used the wrong one? 🤔

“Then you have the chutzpah to immediately follow up with a second post that reads, ‘At the same time, Free Palestine.’

“Seriously? Apologizing for your antisemitism with not one, but two qualifications isn’t an apology at all. It was a reminder that you don’t feel like Jews deserve the same respect as everyone else. That’s not political speech; it’s prejudice — and it’s pathetic.”

On top of everything else this statement is, people should take it as yet another reminder that you should never, ever, ever, EVER apologize for offending Zionists, ever. As Jeremy Corbyn found out, it only encourages more bad faith smears and attacks. It’s like cutting yourself while swimming with mako sharks.

Greenblatt’s emphasis on Yang saying “Free Palestine” tells you what this whole manufactured scandal is actually about. This is about imposing costs for Palestine support and bludgeoning those who speak out against Israeli abuses so that fewer influential voices will be willing to do so.

It is true that actual far right anti-semites like David Duke have used the word “Zio” in reference to Zionists, but it’s also just the first three letters of the word, and young Palestine supporters who’ve never even heard of David Duke started using it a while back as an obvious abbreviation for a term they were frequently using.

I’ve seen Palestine supporters trying to argue in good faith that leftists should avoid the term because of its far right associations, and I’ve always avoided it myself for precisely that reason, but honestly this sort of discourse just gets fucking exhausting when people are trying to oppose an ongoing genocide and resist wars of immense global consequence.

This all boils down to the fact that there are just too many god damn fucking rules about exactly how you’re allowed to criticize Israel and Zionism in a world where Israel and Zionism are inflicting mass atrocities abroad and destroying our civil liberties here at home.

If you want to criticize Israel in the mainstream circles of public influence occupied by people like Bowen Yang, you’re expected to memorize an impossibly long list of no-no words, banned phrases, unacceptable positions and Antisemitic Tropes before you can even open your mouth, and they’re not even comprehensively listed anywhere. You’ve got to avoid any reference to noses, blood, pennies, money, marionette strings, tentacles, wells, any suggestion that anyone of Jewish heritage exerts too much influence in the upper echelons of power, and a million other items that get brought up out of nowhere whenever someone of influence suggests that genocide might be bad.

This is entirely by design. Zionists can’t explicitly tell people that all criticism of Israel is banned without exposing themselves as tyrants, so what they do instead is surround the issue with an impossible-to-navigate barrier of speech land mines so that anyone who says anything about Israel’s abuses can be branded an anti-semite.

A couple of months ago the rapper Macklemore was being aggressively smeared as an antisemite because he said “Free Palestine” at a concert and then Zionists uncovered 2014 photos of him performing with a large fake nose, baselessly claiming he was impersonating a Jewish person. Macklemore said at the time that it was a costume store witch nose he wore as a disguise for a surprise performance, and it is ridiculous to expect a young Irish Catholic rapper from Seattle to have been intimately familiar with the long list of antisemitic tropes. But back in September the ADL was falsely citing the incident to claim that “For years, Macklemore has pushed antisemitic tropes” and has a record of “engaging in antisemitic rhetoric and behavior.”

….

This all boils down to the fact that there are just too many god damn fucking rules about exactly how you’re allowed to criticize Israel and Zionism in a world where Israel and Zionism are inflicting mass atrocities abroad and destroying our civil liberties here at home.

If you want to criticize Israel in the mainstream circles of public influence occupied by people like Bowen Yang, you’re expected to memorize an impossibly long list of no-no words, banned phrases, unacceptable positions and Antisemitic Tropes before you can even open your mouth, and they’re not even comprehensively listed anywhere. You’ve got to avoid any reference to noses, blood, pennies, money, marionette strings, tentacles, wells, any suggestion that anyone of Jewish heritage exerts too much influence in the upper echelons of power, and a million other items that get brought up out of nowhere whenever someone of influence suggests that genocide might be bad.

This is entirely by design. Zionists can’t explicitly tell people that all criticism of Israel is banned without exposing themselves as tyrants, so what they do instead is surround the issue with an impossible-to-navigate barrier of speech land mines so that anyone who says anything about Israel’s abuses can be branded an anti-semite.

A couple of months ago the rapper Macklemore was being aggressively smeared as an antisemite because he said “Free Palestine” at a concert and then Zionists uncovered 2014 photos of him performing with a large fake nose, baselessly claiming he was impersonating a Jewish person. Macklemore said at the time that it was a costume store witch nose he wore as a disguise for a surprise performance, and it is ridiculous to expect a young Irish Catholic rapper from Seattle to have been intimately familiar with the long list of antisemitic tropes. But back in September the ADL was falsely citing the incident to claim that “For years, Macklemore has pushed antisemitic tropes” and has a record of “engaging in antisemitic rhetoric and behavior.”

Video reading by Tim Foley:

https://www.caitlinjohnst.one/p/there-are-too-many-damn-rules-were

0 thoughts on “There Are Too Many Damn Rules We’re Expected To Follow When Criticizing Israel And Zionism”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *